I don't think the way the song was sung is bad so-to-say, buuuuutt, the tempo was too fast, and the melody was too ... upbeat, i mean this song is supposed to be a goodbye! not a "oh well ttyl!" and yes no one can beat Kristen Chenoweth and Idina Menzel, although the people who replaced them in the broadway show are AMAZING, but its not the worst rendition of it i've heard, just doesnt captivate what the song is truly about
You guys are idiots, try getting up on stage infront of millions of viewers, dancing around on stage, performing, and singing all at once. I'm sorry that she isnt the broadway singer that all of you expect, but i hate to break it to you but i bet all of the people you like dont actually sing on their records, and the reason they sound so good live, is because its all pre-recorded and its not them singing at all :) I think people who sing live and dont sound like their record deserve more credit because you know its them singing. idiots.
on Ignorance
at 03:20 10/16/2008
as a reply on the comment by TylerDurden
If you're looking at it that way then i think more important than that, we shouldnt let anyone with German heritage even run for senate or anything, i mean look at WW1 or WW2, lets blame a whole country or a whole religion because of one extremists, or a few, in fact, lets do that to the whole world, lets subdue EVERYONE who has a history with people who have done crime, wait wait wait but then everyone will be subdued, gain a brain, dont judge a person just because of a history of violence associate with a religion HE ISNT EVEN A PART OF!
and awww, i want Ron adn Hermione together forever!